Advice
Why Most Managers Are Terrible at Creative Problem Solving (And How to Actually Fix It)
Related Reading:
The other day I was sitting in a café in Fortitude Valley watching a manager from some tech company absolutely lose his mind over a WiFi outage. Full meltdown. Phone calls to IT, threats to the café staff, the works. Meanwhile, his team just quietly relocated to the co-working space next door and kept working.
That's the problem with most managers today. They've forgotten how to think creatively when problems arise.
After 18 years in workplace training and consulting, I've watched countless managers stumble through crises because they're stuck in linear thinking patterns. They want the handbook solution, the policy answer, the "right" way to handle everything. But here's the uncomfortable truth: the best managers I know are the ones who can think like artists when problems hit.
The Creative Deficit in Management
Most management training focuses on processes, frameworks, and methodologies. All fine and necessary. But when was the last time you saw a manager encouraged to think like a painter approaching a blank canvas? Or a musician improvising during a performance?
I worked with a retail manager in Perth last year who was dealing with chronic staff shortages. Traditional solutions weren't working - higher wages weren't available, recruitment was slow, and existing staff were burning out. Instead of more of the same, she started thinking creatively. She partnered with a local TAFE to offer work experience placements, created flexible micro-shifts for students, and even developed a "bring a friend for training" program that turned recruitment into a social activity.
Revenue increased 23% over six months.
That's creative problem solving in action.
Why Managers Resist Creative Approaches
The resistance to creative thinking in management comes from three main sources: fear of failure, obsession with precedent, and misunderstanding what creativity actually means.
Fear of failure is obvious. Managers are promoted for consistency and risk management. Creative problem solving training often challenges this directly, asking people to experiment and potentially fail in controlled ways.
But the precedent obsession is more insidious. I've seen managers spend hours searching for how other companies handled similar problems instead of spending that time developing novel solutions. Yes, learning from others is valuable. But sometimes your problem is unique, or the standard solution simply won't work in your context.
The biggest misunderstanding? Thinking creativity means chaos.
Creativity isn't about throwing structure out the window. It's about structured experimentation, disciplined imagination, and systematic exploration of possibilities. The best creative problem solvers I know are incredibly methodical about their approach to being creative.
The Three Pillars of Creative Management
Pillar One: Constraint Appreciation
Contrary to popular belief, creativity thrives within constraints, not despite them. Some of the most innovative solutions I've seen came from managers who had almost no budget, limited time, or restrictive policies to work within.
A facilities manager in Adelaide solved a persistent parking problem by turning it into a gamification challenge. Instead of just adding more spaces (expensive) or implementing strict penalties (unpopular), she created a rotating system where different departments "won" prime parking spots each month based on various criteria - punctuality, customer feedback, environmental initiatives. Suddenly, people were carpooling and using public transport to help their team win.
Zero additional cost. Maximum buy-in.
Pillar Two: Perspective Rotation
This is where most managers fail spectacularly. They approach every problem from their own departmental viewpoint. Customer service sees everything as a communication issue. Finance sees everything as a budget problem. HR sees everything as a people challenge.
Creative managers deliberately rotate their perspective. They ask: "How would our biggest competitor handle this? How would a startup approach this? What would a five-year-old suggest? How would we solve this if we had unlimited resources? How would we solve this if we had no resources at all?"
I learned this technique from a manufacturing supervisor who was dealing with quality control issues. Traditional approach would be more inspections, better training, stricter procedures. Instead, he asked his team: "How would a detective solve this problem?" They started mapping patterns, looking for unusual correlations, following evidence trails. They discovered the real issue was humidity fluctuations from a nearby construction project that no one had connected to the quality problems.
Pillar Three: Rapid Prototyping
Most managers overthink solutions before trying them. They want perfect information, complete buy-in, and guaranteed outcomes. Creative managers test small, fast, and cheap.
A retail manager dealing with customer complaints about long queues didn't redesign the entire customer flow system. She just tried having one staff member walk the queue with an iPad, handling simple requests on the spot. Customer satisfaction scores improved within a week. Only then did she invest in a proper queue management system.
The Dark Side of Creative Problem Solving
Here's where I probably lose some readers: not every problem needs a creative solution.
Sometimes the standard approach works perfectly well. Sometimes creativity is just procrastination in disguise. I've worked with managers who turned simple scheduling conflicts into elaborate brainstorming sessions because they enjoyed the creative process more than the mundane work of actually managing.
The trick is knowing when to be creative and when to just fix the damn problem with conventional methods.
Also, creative solutions often create new problems. That retail manager with the staff shortage solution? Three months later she was dealing with complex scheduling conflicts and training coordination challenges she never had before. Worth it, but not without costs.
Building Creative Capacity
If you want to become better at creative problem solving as a manager, start with these practical steps:
Change Your Information Diet
Stop reading only business publications. Pick up magazines from completely different industries. I get ideas for workplace training from cooking magazines, skateboarding blogs, and urban planning journals. Cross-pollination of ideas is where creativity lives.
Practise Constraint Challenges
Once a month, give yourself an artificial constraint when solving routine problems. Solve the next budget issue as if you only had 24 hours. Handle the next customer complaint as if email didn't exist. Approach the next team conflict as if you could only communicate through drawings.
These sound silly, but they break you out of default thinking patterns.
Find Your Creative Triggers
Everyone has different conditions that spark creative thinking. Some people need complete silence. Others need background noise. Some think best while walking. Others while sitting still. Figure out your optimal creative environment and use it deliberately when facing challenging problems.
I do my best creative problem solving in the car. No idea why. So when I'm stuck on a particularly tricky client situation, I'll often drive to the office via the scenic route instead of working through it at my desk.
The ROI of Creative Management
Here's the business case for creative problem solving that CFOs actually care about: creative managers consistently outperform conventional managers on both cost savings and revenue generation.
A study I came across suggested that managers who regularly use creative problem-solving techniques save their organisations an average of 31% more annually compared to those who rely solely on standard procedures. They're also 47% more likely to identify new revenue opportunities.
But beyond the numbers, creative managers create more engaging workplaces. Their teams report higher job satisfaction, lower stress levels, and better collaboration. When people see their manager thinking creatively, they feel permission to do the same.
What This Means for You
The shift from conventional to creative management isn't about becoming an artist or throwing logic out the window. It's about expanding your toolkit, becoming comfortable with uncertainty, and recognising that most business problems have multiple valid solutions.
Start small. Next time you face a workplace challenge, spend fifteen minutes generating unconventional solutions before falling back on standard approaches. Ask someone from a completely different department how they might handle it. Look into some structured creative problem solving approaches that give you frameworks for innovative thinking.
The managers who thrive in the next decade won't be the ones who follow procedures most accurately. They'll be the ones who can think creatively when procedures aren't enough.
And in a world where procedures are increasingly automated, creative problem solving might be the most essential management skill of all.
Looking to develop creative problem solving skills in your team? Check out these professional development opportunities designed specifically for managers and team leaders.